Hello,
Sorry for the late reply.
Quote:
Did you check the fuses? F1 and F2 are near the top right corner of the IDE header while F3 is above and to the left of the motor controller.
I did a continuity check of all three F1, F2 and F3 fuses. My multimeter beeps for for each fuse: continuity is OK for all three fuses, on both PCBs.
Quote:
Did you measure the resistances of the motor windings (phase-to-common and phase-to-phase)?
I am not sure about the procedure for phase-to-common and phase-to-phase testing, but I measured the resistances at the motor connector pins (those who connect to the PCB). They are either 2.65Ω (+/- 0.05Ω) or the double 5.3V (+/- 0.1Ω).
I compared with sightly more recent tested IBM Travelstar, and ─ although the pinout is different, with larger pads ─ the measured values are same (2.7 and 5.4V). So I presume the motor is OK.
Quote:
If the drive is waiting for a spin-up signal or command, it should still identify itself via an ATA Identify Device command, I would think.
I did one additional check inserting the drive directly in a working Acer Aspire 1200 series (almost as antique, from the Windows XP era): the HDD doesn't spin after powering the laptop on. I could check by not closing the HDD niche and check with my finger that there was no vibration.
Quote:
When each PCB is detached from the HDD and powered on, I measure no voltage at each of the 4 motor-pins, below the square-shaped hole.
I had wrongly measured VDC instead of VAC.
Testing PCB motor pins on PCBs from working 10GB or 20GB IBM Travelstar DJSA drives, I measure voltages around ~0.13-0.15 V(AC) with my Fluke 70, and similar value at 130 millivolt with a more accurate Fluke 87 (True RMS) multimeter.
For the PCB of the IBM Travelstar 4.86GB DBCA series, I measure voltages of only 3-7 millivolts ; and same for the donor board.
Additionally, when connecting the PCBs (alone) from working drive are connected to my Sharkoon QuickPort Combo hard drive docking station, its diodes are "Blue/ Blue" (i.e. OK), whilst for the not spinning drives the diodes are "Blue/Red", typical of defective drives.
So, I presume the received hard drive has a dead PCB board, and the board received being also defective.
I noticed that the Bluestork enclosure in which I received the hard drive is not keyed and you can easily accidentally offset the HDD by one pin.
As I tested the HDD directly with my docking station cable hardness, I didn't pay attention whether the HDD has possibly been wrongly inserted by the client. There are however no visible burnt components nor smell of anything.