almonime wrote:
well, from my experiance thus far ( and let me tall ya, i gained a lot )
every surface scan i do (with meny different softwares ) comes clean and the hd has no bad sectors what so ever.
so it seems there are two scenerios :
1. the softwares i tried have full access to the entire hd surface, there are really no bad sectors on the hd and the
SMART attribute is a bogus one because of the power failure
...
This is incorrect. These softwares do not have full access to the drive surface. They see what the drive's controller wants them to see: a nice, continuous, defect-free surface. The drive does all the remapping of sectors behind the scenes. MHDD and Victoria are about as good as you're going to get for surface analysis, because they are reading every sector and timing how long it takes, which is a pretty good indication in many cases of an impending failure.
almonime wrote:
...
2. the softwares access the sectors that are registerd as GOOD ( remapped sectors in GLIST ) and by doing so,thay
not really access the bad sectors. that is why every surface scan come clean.
...
Correct.
almonime wrote:
...
clearing the GLIST will prevent bogus notification in case 1 or will grant access to the bad sectors in case 2 which i can try to fix and if thay are really bad, fine, at list i tried.
Like BlackST said, it's not an erroneous notification. Your drive more than likely does have that many bad sectors.
Here's what will happen if you reset the glist contents:
- You will write data to your hard disk.
- Some will be written to questionable areas of the disk.
- Some of those sectors will immediately be remapped, so no harm will be done.
- Information written to areas that are questionable, but not so bad, will work at first, then more and more of them will start to fail or produce incorrect reads.
- Your data is corrupted.
- The bad sectors are once again added to the glist, but too late to save you from a major headache that could have been avoided if you took a failing drive and threw it in the garbage, rather than trying to "fix" it and put it back into service.
You can't fix bad sectors, you can only hide them. When a drive starts to get that many bad sectors, it's the symptom of a problem, as in your drive has a problem. It won't go away, and it can't be fixed with effort and/or money in a justifiable amount toward the continued use of your hard disk. Just throw it in the garbage, ok?