madprofessor wrote:The drive isn't bad
I politely disagree - you do not have enough info to be so certain IMHO.
madprofessor wrote:I have tried to format this in Ubuntu, Windows 7 and Windows XP. All three recognize the drive. All three see the partitions however when I try to delete the partitions they each give me an error. Ubuntu is "Daemon is inhibited." And both Windows give me an unspecified error.
A drive which "isn't bad" is unlikely to cause these symptoms! Unfortunately, there is insufficient detail in your comment so far, to get a better diagnosis of how the drive is behaving incorrectly.
If this was my system, I would be reviewing the detailed error logs for the relevant times, on each OS you have mentioned (remember that both Linux & Windows have them), and not just using whatever message is displayed on the GUI, since "unspecified error" is not useful for further diagnosis. I would also collect & review the full SMART data for the drive, and perhaps use a DOS-based drive utility e.g. MHDD - your comments suggest the drive may read successfully, but report errors only when writing, for example. MHDD allows that type of hypothesis to be tested.
Although you say it's a Maxtor-branded drive, I expect that Seagate SeaTools (or whatever is recommended for your specific drive, if different - your drive's model number doesn't seem to be given by you yet), would be a good utility for you to run. Visit Seagate's website and find your drive model in their support section.
I suspect that
loki's suggestion will end up being correct, but I have given you some options above to allow you to do further troubleshooting, provided that you remain open-minded to the possibility of your initial statement above being incorrect. Good luck with whatever you decide