Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 with seized spindle.

[DanR]

An external drive arrived in the office today with a seized spindle. The closest donor part we have in stock is as follows:

Client Drive
Seagate Barracuda 7200.11
Model : ST3400620A
P/N : 9BJ044-305
Firmware : 3.AAE
Date Code : 07302
Site Code : TK

Possible Donor Drive
Seagate Barracuda 7200.11
Model : ST3500630A
P/N : 9BJ046-305
Firmware : 3.AAE
Date Code : 07466
Site Code : TK

Because it's a seized spindle I only require the chassis to be identical, Would these drives be compatible?

Also, Does the 7200.11 series use acoustic spacers?

Many thanks,
-DR

[Nick_CT]

I only require the chassis to be identical

Have you done this procedure before?

[BlackST]

Have you done this procedure before?

Also, Does the 7200.11 series use acoustic spacers?

That's the answer.

[DanR]

Have you done this procedure before?

Also, Does the 7200.11 series use acoustic spacers?

That's the answer.

A simple yes/no answer would have been fine.

[hddguy]

An external drive arrived in the office today with a seized spindle. The closest donor part we have in stock is as follows:


Seagate Barracuda 7200.11
Model : ST3400620A
P/N : 9BJ044-305
Firmware : 3.AAE
Date Code : 07302
Site Code : TK


Seagate Barracuda 7200.11
Model : ST3500630A
P/N : 9BJ046-305
Firmware : 3.AAE
Date Code : 07466
Site Code : TK

You are sure these are correct details???

[customukr]

A simple yes/no answer on HDDGuru forums? Not possible I'm afraid.

[BlackST]

It's just NOT a matter of identical "chassis".

IF the spindle was seized because of DROPPED DRIVE, inspect the pack especially at H0 side for "surprises"
THEN, you'll potentially face two other problems : possible shift and leveling.

[DanR]

An external drive arrived in the office today with a seized spindle. The closest donor part we have in stock is as follows:


Seagate Barracuda 7200.11
Model : ST3400620A
P/N : 9BJ044-305
Firmware : 3.AAE
Date Code : 07302
Site Code : TK


Seagate Barracuda 7200.11
Model : ST3500630A
P/N : 9BJ046-305
Firmware : 3.AAE
Date Code : 07466
Site Code : TK

You are sure these are correct details???

Ah, I have spotted my mistake. The drive is a Barracuda 7200.10

[northwind]

The models you describe are .10, not .11.

[northwind]

The first one is 2-platter drive, while the second one is 3-platter.
Also, .10 's are tough ones on platter swap.
I suggest to practice A LOT before trying on customer drives.

[DanR]

The first one is 2-platter drive, while the second one is 3-platter.
Also, .10 's are tough ones on platter swap.
I suggest to practice A LOT before trying on customer drives.

Thank you. Can you confirm that they have spacers?

[hddguy]

A simple yes/no answer on HDDGuru forums? Not possible I'm afraid.

If I were to ask you to give to me all the information and knowledge you have spent many years (or 17 months) researching and learning, would you give it to me with nothing in return?

For the most part here people are willing to help, will share knowledge and offer friendly assistance. But sometimes giving this help only complicates issues, such as giving a newbie tips on platter alignment during his attempts at physical repairs on a clients HDD without having any prior experience or knowledge on HDD repairs.

Sometimes I feel that new DR companies are formed with no real basis or experience in DR who become solely dependant on hddguru for answers! This is bad for many reasons, I should not need to explain!

On the other hand, harmless advice is almost always given and information / knowledge is very often exchanged here whether in PM or in public forum. And in most cases , simple yes/no answer is not possible...

Last edited by hddguy on May 24th, 2012, 8:16, edited 1 time in total.

[hddguy]

The first one is 2-platter drive, while the second one is 3-platter.
Also, .10 's are tough ones on platter swap.
I suggest to practice A LOT before trying on customer drives.

Thank you. Can you confirm that they have spacers?

they do.

If you are not comfortable with this, outsource it. You can easily find a reputable DR firm local to you who have high experience on this common HDD and common problem.

If you attempt yourself and lose alignment, even slightly, there is a chance that data will become unrecoverable, or if recoverable will be at a significantly higher cost.

[customukr]

A simple yes/no answer on HDDGuru forums? Not possible I'm afraid.

If I were to ask you to give to me all the information and knowledge you have spent many years (or 17 months) researching and learning, would you give it to me with nothing in return?

For the most part here people are willing to help, will share knowledge and offer friendly assistance. But sometimes giving this help only complicates issues, such as giving a newbie tips on platter alignment during his attempts at physical repairs on a clients HDD without having any prior experience or knowledge on HDD repairs.

Sometimes I feel that new DR companies are formed with no real basis or experience in DR who become solely dependant on hddguru for answers! This is bad for many reasons, I should not need to explain!

On the other hand, harmless advice is almost always given and information / knowledge is very often exchanged here whether in PM or in public forum. And in most cases , simple yes/no answer is not possible...

Hence why I said, not possible

[Touchclarity]

A simple search on this forum will tell you that your concerns over Acoustic spacers means that you are heading in the wrong direction with this case....