Data recovery and disk repair questions and discussions related to old-fashioned SATA, SAS, SCSI, IDE, MFM hard drives - any type of storage device that has moving parts
Post a reply

External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

August 29th, 2022, 5:29

Hello

This Back up plus slim (inside is a ST500-LT012) used like this with root partition as sdx1, has some weird smart data in n°193 attribute : high raw value increasing rapidly and regularly when the disk is used
today 337603 > was around 1000 in last november when I began to use it (10 hours daily)

Is this a sign of a bad trend for the life of this disk ?

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

August 29th, 2022, 14:30

193 it is load/unload cycle count
I ve never seen this with other hard disks

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

August 29th, 2022, 14:46

The drive appears to have an aggressive APM setting. Examine your power management options.

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

September 2nd, 2022, 5:15

I don't know how to do this on Linux because when looking to gnome-disks APM settings for this disk, it appears as disabled, but though I can enable it if needed
Are you though considering the settings in Linux Mint Cinnamon Parameters ? "Power management" > "Suspend when inactive" is on Never

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

September 2nd, 2022, 22:18

Menard wrote:I don't know how to do this on Linux because when looking to gnome-disks APM settings for this disk, it appears as disabled, but though I can enable it if needed
Are you though considering the settings in Linux Mint Cinnamon Parameters ? "Power management" > "Suspend when inactive" is on Never


No. Look into the 'hdparm' utilities - the ones you're interested in are:

hdparm -B xxx /dev/sdX

and

hdparm -S xx /dev/sdX

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

September 4th, 2022, 6:15

Platters_n_Heads wrote:
Menard wrote:I don't know how to do this on Linux because when looking to gnome-disks APM settings for this disk, it appears as disabled, but though I can enable it if needed
Are you though considering the settings in Linux Mint Cinnamon Parameters ? "Power management" > "Suspend when inactive" is on Never


No. Look into the 'hdparm' utilities - the ones you're interested in are:

hdparm -B xxx /dev/sdX

and

hdparm -S xx /dev/sdX



This gives with sudo :
xxx: No such file or directory
and
-S: bad/missing standby-interval value (0..255)

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

September 4th, 2022, 16:06

OK I ve found a tutorial, so
- with -B > APM_level = 128 > I ve read that 128 doesn't allow the spin down
- with -S > I don't know how to get the value

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

September 4th, 2022, 18:04

Doing anything via USB is complicated. Even if you succeed in directly communicating with the HDD and changing its APM setting, it may be that the bridge firmware is also imposing its own power management regime. Also, if the OS is periodically querying the USB mass storage device, that would cause the drive to be woken up.

Re: External Seagate used for system partition (Linux Mint)

September 5th, 2022, 4:02

To get the smart data I am allready communicating with the HDD, I had to boot on another Linux Mint with the default USB driver disabled
but I understand that it can be still limited. I ve also read that these HDD and the more recent of this type have limitation in their communication functions in themselves
Post a reply