Switch to full style
Data recovery and disk repair questions and discussions related to old-fashioned SATA, SAS, SCSI, IDE, MFM hard drives - any type of storage device that has moving parts
Post a reply

WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered now

September 24th, 2020, 11:38

Many of you probable seen Spyglass, Palmer, or Charger drives that return all zeros on a read data request. It is because these drives have damaged or empty SMR translator.
I was working on this problem for a long time and now I can say that I finally have a decent solution.

The best results can be achieved if SMR translator is only partially damaged but I can also recover drives that were re-formatted (in this case SMR translator is completely erased).
Unfortunately I cannot recover these remotely only if you ship the drive to me.

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 24th, 2020, 12:16

nice job, congrats!

i also made some but probably little progress in this matter (compared to your results).

pepe

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 24th, 2020, 12:17

pepe wrote:nice job, congrats!

i also made some but probably little progress in this matter (compared to your results).

pepe

Thank you Peter!

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 24th, 2020, 14:06

Well done.
With complete folder structure recovery ? or RAW recovery ?

Great job.

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 24th, 2020, 14:39

unknown wrote:With complete folder structure recovery ? or RAW recovery ?

Yes, with file names and all the folder structure
unknown wrote:Great job.

Thank you

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 24th, 2020, 14:43

Doomer wrote:
unknown wrote:With complete folder structure recovery ? or RAW recovery ?

Yes, with file names and all the folder structure
unknown wrote:Great job.

Thank you

That's looks promising, very great work indeed.

Keep up the good work :good: :good: :good:

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 26th, 2020, 7:09

Oh my, that's quite a puzzle you solved then. Very impressive.

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 28th, 2020, 13:31

Congratulationssssssssssssssssss, That is big jump :idea:

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 28th, 2020, 18:13

Kudos!!! Great work!!

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 28th, 2020, 18:57

Great work guys. Very impressive.

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 29th, 2020, 6:15

well done...

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 30th, 2020, 12:28

Well,
Let The Debate Start ,Sorry Doomer In Advance ,Whats Th Price Per TB Of HDD Space ,I am Sure Its Definately Not Affordable Right ,Just Like Always Its Been With You 5 or 10 Top Pros .I Was Quoted USD 2000 for a RAW Files Recovery Few Days Before Acelab Released Ver 6.7 .I also Assume Few Of These Pros Are In The Beta Testers Of Acelab And They Get To Use The Technology Before Its Released ,I am Not Saying Acelab Can Also Do What Doomer Claims To Say Here But Who The Hell Knows .Like That SM Series 22XX SSD That Has All The Tools In Public Domain In China Along With Many Firmwares Etc Etc .

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

September 30th, 2020, 14:00

Amarbir[CDR-Labs] wrote:Well,
Let The Debate Start ,Sorry Doomer In Advance ,Whats Th Price Per TB Of HDD Space ,I am Sure Its Definately Not Affordable Right ,Just Like Always Its Been With You 5 or 10 Top Pros .

Looks more like accusation not a debate, really :D
I PMed you the price.

Amarbir[CDR-Labs] wrote:I Was Quoted USD 2000 for a RAW Files Recovery Few Days Before Acelab Released Ver 6.7

It's useless for drives with encryption, which is majority of drives where I work.
My solution works on encrypted drives.
Amarbir[CDR-Labs] wrote:And They Get To Use The Technology Before Its Released

I'm sure "they" do, not sure why you trying to accuse me of being one of "them" :shock:

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

October 9th, 2020, 17:39

Forgot to add, I can also recover TRIM-ed files on WD SMR.

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

October 10th, 2020, 19:35

Well done.
I think that was big PITA and a lot of R&D that may took month/s without stopping.

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

October 12th, 2020, 14:53

Doomer ,
The Price You Quoted Was Exceptional ,This Is How It Should Be ,Not That USD 2000 Type ,How The Hell Can We Developing Countries Afford That ,Your Price is Very Good i Have Several Cases Lined Up For You

PS : Doomer is The First Sensible Guy i Have Met In Relation To Pricing .Great Job

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

October 13th, 2020, 12:20

2k price probably was before puplic release of same solution. After release, price should be reconsidered. You should repsect guys who is doing R&D separate to Acelab, and gaining faster results with own unique methodics.
For some cases , Sandforce SSD for example, cost is still yet to be high, for example. This is kind of coverage of own time investment

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

October 14th, 2020, 0:12

DR-Kiev wrote:2k price probably was before puplic release of same solution. After release, price should be reconsidered. You should repsect guys who is doing R&D separate to Acelab, and gaining faster results with own unique methodics.
For some cases , Sandforce SSD for example, cost is still yet to be high, for example. This is kind of coverage of own time investment


Well,
2K For RAW Recovery Is Not What Our customers Can Pay ,You Can See Even Acelabs Solution is Useless even now ,I have never got any sensible output even in RAW and its DAMMMMMMM SLOWWWWWWW .

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

October 14th, 2020, 4:19

Ace solution with raw recovery using PBA is not applicable to drives with encryption IMHO.
It works well with drives without hw encryption which is 5%? of the drives we see, at least here.

Edit: I see Doomer already mentioned this.

Re: WD SMR drives that return "all zeros" can be recovered n

October 19th, 2020, 5:35

Amarbir[CDR-Labs] wrote:Doomer ,
The Price You Quoted Was Exceptional ,This Is How It Should Be ,Not That USD 2000 Type ,How The Hell Can We Developing Countries Afford That ,Your Price is Very Good i Have Several Cases Lined Up For You

PS : Doomer is The First Sensible Guy i Have Met In Relation To Pricing .Great Job



Don't forget that in other countries the living cost isn't the same as yours. I've lived in France , Brazil and currently Tunisia, my prices depends on where i live and not how much a person from the UK, US or EU asks.

if the provider can make a better price for someone that lives in another country, where the living cost is much lower, then this person is a good one.
Post a reply