Can anyone confirm whether the ST3000VN000 (Family: 59-Bacall) requires platter alignment?
I have a drive with damaged heads and need to inspect the platters for surface damage. Any confirmation or guidance would be appreciated.

Mark platters and put them back the same way. Never had a problem with those.

_________________
odzyskiwanie danych

Yeah, it does. The ST3000VN000 (59-Bacall) uses platter “stack alignment” and if you break the stack orientation (or mix platters/spacers), you can easily end up with tracks not lining up and the drive won’t read anything even with good heads.

If your goal is only to inspect for surface damage, you *can* open it, but don’t loosen the spindle/clamp or separate platters unless you have proper alignment tools and a clean environment. Head damage usually leaves visible rings/scratches where the head scraped the surface, so you can often spot it with a careful visual check without disturbing the stack.

If the data matters, safest move is don’t mess with the platters at all and hand it to a recovery shop. One slip or dust = permanent loss.

Be wary that besides platter alignment, there is also a servo track for the controller to use to find track zero etc

One time with a disk I opened it in a clean room and replaced the metal cover with a plexiglass one so that disk activity could be seen. The disk was obsolete so it was no loss if the experiment failed.

_________________
Orico DS500C3-US-BK 5-disk 3.5" SATA, iTGZ 4x M.2 2280 Thunderbolt enclosure NVMe/SATA, etc. etc.