pcimage wrote:
On certain older drives (such as Maxtor Calypso, Quantum etc), then yes it would probably work.
But more modern drives have very specific ROM versions on the PCB which must match EXACTLY to the firmware on the drives platters. And many of the new drives have UNIQUE information programmed into the ROM
These new Seagate drives in particular have unique info. In fact if I connect just a 7200.11 PCB alone (i.e. not even connected to the hard drive itself) I can still see the model and serial number of the drive (through the serial connection using specialist equipment), showing that the PCB IS unique.
This was further confirmed by swapping the PCB's from two IDENTICAL drives from a raid 0 (striped) configuration. Neither worked until the ROM was transferred, then both drives worked fine again.
Again, what are the symptoms of your problem? Dead? Clicking? Not seen in BIOS?
Sean, let him try........sometimes we just need to step aside after we give our opinion.
To antec35 :
let's hope you will not make your drive worst. Any attempt to replace any component of the PCB (which is of course dangerous for some brand and models) is probably the cheapest method you can try. Just want to remind you, if things get worse than it is now, probably DR company will quote more than 900 USD