Switch to full style
Data recovery and disk repair questions and discussions related to old-fashioned SATA, SAS, SCSI, IDE, MFM hard drives - any type of storage device that has moving parts
Post a reply

Platter with scratches. Can the manufacturer fix it?

December 6th, 2023, 15:26

Hi there. I have a Western Digital My Book Studio 2TB. One platter unfortunately has scratches and it kills heads, so data can't be pulled from there.
My question is, does the manufacturer (I know that they're not in the data recovery business) have machines that can make the surface of those platters smooth again so that heads won't break? Machines not available to the general public or data recovery businesses, for instance what about the glide and burnish machine?
Thank you.

Re: Platter with scratches. Can the manufacturer fix it?

December 6th, 2023, 15:46

No, whey will not fix it. Why even try? If there's scratch on one surface, you cut this head and try to read from others.

Re: Platter with scratches. Can the manufacturer fix it?

December 7th, 2023, 11:02

whatifwe wrote:Hi there. I have a Western Digital My Book Studio 2TB. One platter unfortunately has scratches and it kills heads, so data can't be pulled from there.
My question is, does the manufacturer (I know that they're not in the data recovery business) have machines that can make the surface of those platters smooth again so that heads won't break? Machines not available to the general public or data recovery businesses, for instance what about the glide and burnish machine?
Thank you.


Why would they have such machines? It's 100 times cheaper to just send new drives.

Ah, the burnish device, https://www.mratek.com/MRA/Products.html

Re: Platter with scratches. Can the manufacturer fix it?

December 8th, 2023, 15:55

Arch Stanton wrote:
whatifwe wrote:Hi there. I have a Western Digital My Book Studio 2TB. One platter unfortunately has scratches and it kills heads, so data can't be pulled from there.
My question is, does the manufacturer (I know that they're not in the data recovery business) have machines that can make the surface of those platters smooth again so that heads won't break? Machines not available to the general public or data recovery businesses, for instance what about the glide and burnish machine?
Thank you.


Why would they have such machines? It's 100 times cheaper to just send new drives.

Ah, the burnish device, https://www.mratek.com/MRA/Products.html


Yes but new drives do not contain my data.
So what's your opinion on the burnish device?

Re: Platter with scratches. Can the manufacturer fix it?

December 9th, 2023, 14:35

whatifwe wrote:
Arch Stanton wrote:
whatifwe wrote:Hi there. I have a Western Digital My Book Studio 2TB. One platter unfortunately has scratches and it kills heads, so data can't be pulled from there.
My question is, does the manufacturer (I know that they're not in the data recovery business) have machines that can make the surface of those platters smooth again so that heads won't break? Machines not available to the general public or data recovery businesses, for instance what about the glide and burnish machine?
Thank you.


Why would they have such machines? It's 100 times cheaper to just send new drives.

Ah, the burnish device, https://www.mratek.com/MRA/Products.html


Yes but new drives do not contain my data.
So what's your opinion on the burnish device?


Yes, so Why would they have such machines?.

I don't have an opinion on those machines.

Re: Platter with scratches. Can the manufacturer fix it?

December 9th, 2023, 14:58

Gillware burnish/glide machine:

https://forum.hddguru.com/viewtopic.php?t=30853
Post a reply