freeballt wrote:
Getting a new PCB would cost me around 70 dollars (for a new hard drive), and that would be cheaper then having some one one look at it.
I have a degree in computer science and electrical engineering, but no experience with hard drives and how they work. I just want to see if I can have this fixed myself without going to some one or having it sent in for data recovery.
I feel there can be 3 problems, with the individual components. Either a bad PCB, seized motor or destroyed platters. If its a bad PCB, replace it with the exact model/make, seized motor - transplant it, destroyed platters... end game.
I just need some suggestions the symptoms I had described above.
There are definitely more than 3 possible problems, but anyway. I would be willing to bet that 2 of the problems can be handled by someone who does know about hard drives for around $100. With a degree in EE, you should definitely not be looking at replacing the PCB to fix the problem. While the issue may be there, it is not always as simple as just swapping the board. Even when there is a 100% match visually, data that is unique to each disk is stored onboard. You would be better off pulling out a meter and start checking. Start using that EE to find the issue. If it is not on the PCB, I give you a .1% chance of repair. Sorry, but that is the way it is.